The boys are at it again. I use
boys pointedly and advisedly. The guys in the Vatican cannot
tolerate honest women who think for themselves, tell the truth
and put Gospel values above conformity and submission to Vatican
appointed males.
- Nuns in the United States have educated many of us,
our parents, and our grandparents, built hospitals and
cared for our sick and poor all the while on slave wages
and in quiet subservience to boy bishops and cardinals
who never developed psychosexual maturity and balance in
their homosocial bubble; there they wrap themselves in
pretty - I repeat pretty dresses, and expensive - I
repeat expensive hats protected by toadies who agree and
adulate them as if boyfriends.
Nuns paid attention to the voice of the Vatican
Council. Vatican II changed things for all women. They became
part of the People of God. Nuns increased and accelerated their
own education (there are more nuns than priests with earned
masters and doctoral degrees).
- Sr. Mary Luke Tobin, S.L. was one of the few nuns
allowed to be an auditor at the council, but she could
stand shoulder to shoulder spiritually and
intellectually with any of the best men there. She could
recall by heart to her dying day the pledge of the
document Gaudium et Spes, "With respect to the
fundamental rights of the person, every type of
discrimination, whether social, cultural, whether based
on sex, race, color, social condition, language or
religion, is to be overcome and eradicated as contrary
to God's intent." We are all one in Jesus Christ.
The boys have forgotten the primacy of
that doctrine and the importance of conscience. They think that
American nuns spend too much effort on eradicating poverty and
injustice. The boys want nuns to "talk" about important
doctrinal issues like abortion, contraception, premarital
cohabitation and same-sex marriage. They want nuns to spend more
energy like bishops do - fighting sex, namely, everybody else's
sex.
- Bishops are more than reluctant to step up to the
plate to answer the myriad questions about their sexual
play (crimes) with children, affairs with grown women
and men (and each other). They are not reluctant to
spend their time, money and energy covering up their
sexual lives and covering up their cover-ups. That price
tag is close to a billion dollars. But nuns must be
quiet and conform. Consciences be damned.
For instance Tommy Olmsted a person innocent of any
expertise in medicine or the medical ethics procedures that
hospitals employ, from his throne in Phoenix excommunicated Sr.
Margaret McBride, R.S.M. who heads St. Joseph's Hospital,
despite scrupulously following ethically appropriate procedures
in the difficult medical case of an abortion to save a life.
Like a sixth grade boy on the playground he threw his hissy fit
because she did not "respect my authority".
Bishops do not like women they can't control. In
fact, many bishops don't like women. Women threaten their
authority; little girls who surround bishops can be managed and
even manipulated.
- I was in a Vatican room with Pope John Paul II in
1993 when he said that he as pope did not have the
authority to change the rules on celibacy; and it goes
without saying the same holds true in Vatican minds
about the ordination of women to the priesthood. Fr. Roy
Bourgeois, M.M. ruffled the boys club feathers by
attending the ordination of a woman. His support of an
issue that an ever-increasing proportion of Catholics
also support merited him dismissal from the Maryknoll
fathers and the penalty of a Roman excommunication.
Abuse of children merits far more tolerance,
understanding and even personal support than adult
dissent and dialogue. That would not be the case if
women could be priests. Pope John Paul II literally
embraced two clerics who without doubt sexually abused
young men: Cardinal Hans Groer of Austria was a close
personal friend of John Paul. Despite this he was forced
to resign by courageous fellow bishops. (Real men those
Austrians.) Father Marcial Maciel the discredited
founder of the Legionaries of Christ was disciplined
already in 1948 for sexual misbehavior and later
reported to Rome for grave sexual offences years before
John Paul put his arms around him in 2004 at a public
audience. After all boys will be boys. They are out of
their depth in dialogue. They dare not stray into adult
territory where issues of equality and justice prevail.
It is above their developmental grade and comfort level.
They all quickly disavow responsibility for their
conspiratorial part in countenancing abusive priests.
The Vatican's boy, Peter Sartain former bishop of
Joliet, is now sent to investigate head-strong and devout nuns
who head up the Leadership Conference of Women Religious. He
presided over one of the dioceses most resistive to openness and
transparency about its documentation of clergy abuse. In
contrast, women who have led the LCWR are vigorous adults with a
sense of right and courage unmatched by most bishops. Sister
Theresa Kane, R.S.M. spoke directly and openly to the pope in
1979 about the rights of women to the squirms and gasps of the
boys in the pews - she wasn't playing fair speaking frankly,
with respect as one adult to another. That's not the way the
boys play the game - don't women know about all the secret
handshakes that have to be observed?
- Sister Joan Chittister, O.S.B. is spiritually and
character-wise superior to any of the boys in their
flowing silk skirts and lace who are out to investigate
the doctrinal purity of American nuns (that 2008
visitation report is not yet public) and bishops now aim
their sights on the LCWR. Chittister led the LCWR in its
early days and helped set its course solidly in the
Vatican II tradition. Their strength is in willingness
to dialogue about important issues that effect people's
lives not just blindly echo doctrinal pronouncements.
Catholic women theologians are another cause for
the boys' fear and envy. Sister Elizabeth Johnson, C.S.J.,
author of Quest for the Living God, is currently widely
considered the best Catholic theologian in the United States.
Her book raised close and restrictive scrutiny - all but an
outright condemnation - by the authority of the American Bishops
Conference.
- If these are the women leading the "radical feminist
agenda" the Vatican is so worried about more power to
them. They lead the solid Christian way in the tradition
of American nuns. They are involved in leadership not
politics.
Paul Claudel said, "The church turns to politics
when it fails to produce enough saints". Today that is exactly
where the Vatican and American Catholic church are - looking for
political power and passing up and impeding the strength and
sanctity in the corps of women most dedicated to Christian
service, its method and message.
The boys just can't compete. Women
won't play their game.